Who are we to judge?

I’m not sure what to make of your August article looking at the legacy of the Skolfield family and its “ties to slave economy.” The article seems to suggest that we would all do well to “reexamine” this family and its legacy in the light of “new research.”

Is this history new? I would have thought it safe to assume that any family in the business of making and sailing ships in the Atlantic during that time period would deal in the trading of commodities in demand in Europe. Some of those commodities, we know, were produced in a system that, at that time, was the production norm for those goods. We know the horrors of that system and its terrible legacy in this country.

Yet, we are all a product of our times, and it seems this article is asking us to judge the legacy of this family by viewing it through our current racial and social lens. There is even a suggestion, not explicit but still present, that maybe using the family name on buildings and trails would be somehow inappropriate. Are there any statues we could topple while we are at it?

Who are we to judge or cast aspersions on those who came before us and were as much products of their times as we are of ours? Who are we to judge, with our computer devices and electric cars that source materials for their screens and batteries from global markets that rely on deeply problematic and exploitative labor systems, including slave-like conditions for workers, many of them children, from China to Chad?

No, thank you. I will continue to honor current and former members of that family who built and preserved that magnificent barn and those amazing apple trees marking entrance to our beautiful town.

Joe Grady, Harpswell Neck

Related Posts
Read more

Embarrassed for all of Harpswell

I believe I know my place in Harpswell: alien/not from here. That said, I have had the good fortune of being part of the town's Affordable Housing Working Group and providing the group's report, which has been approved by the Select Board, to the Comprehensive Plan Task Force.
Read more

Strongest support for Chipman

I write in strongest support for the reelection of Harpswell Select Board member David Chipman. The duties and responsibilities of the Select Board are critical to a well-functioning, economically responsible town government.
Read more

24/7 firefighter coverage needed now

From Ellen Glew: Remember those postcards saying the town needed to bring in a qualified consultant to develop a comprehensive strategic plan (like the one done in 2008) for Harpswell's fire and rescue services? And that this should be done before approving $6 million for a new emergency services building?
Read more

Town should keep us informed

From Liz Taylor: Thank you, Anchor, for your article in June about the challenges facing the new Emergency Services Building Committee ("Emergency services building project faces rising costs, possible delays," Page 12).

Thank you for your interest in receiving emails from the Harpswell Anchor! It may take a couple days for you to start receiving emails. If you have any questions, please contact info@harpswellanchor.org.

Sign up to receive email updates from the Anchor

← Back

Thank you!

Thank you for your interest in receiving emails from the Harpswell Anchor! It may take a couple days for you to start receiving emails. If you have any questions, please contact info@harpswellanchor.org.

Total
0
Share