|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Residents frustrated by rising property taxes are urging Maine School Administrative District 75 to rein in spending, complicating the school board’s plans to seek voter approval for up to $135 million in building improvements.
At a Nov. 9 budget forum, a group of residents described the growing financial burden on retirees and working families, questioned the district’s spending priorities and called for greater restraint in developing next year’s budget. MSAD 75 covers Harpswell, Topsham, Bowdoin and Bowdoinham.
The concerns come as the district weighs an ambitious overhaul of its aging school buildings, including the possible replacement of Harpswell Community School. Board members who had been leaning toward a comprehensive, $135 million borrowing proposal say they are now reconsidering that approach in light of residents’ objections.
Board member Andy Begin, of Bowdoinham, chair of the board’s Facilities Committee, said previous community discussions had led the board to believe a comprehensive approach was the favored solution, but now it is having second thoughts.
“We can’t ignore the need; we can’t do nothing,” Begin said at the board’s Nov. 12 meeting in Topsham, a few days after the budget forum. “We need to figure out what will be an acceptable answer for our community. … The whole-meal deal is probably not the solution that we want to recommend.”
The two issues are related but involve separate decisions. The district’s operating budget for the 2027-28 school year, which will go before voters in June, will not include the proposed facilities bond. Any borrowing for the long-range facilities master plan, developed by architectural firm Harriman, would require a separate referendum.
The district has five elementary schools, one middle school and one high school, in addition to four other facilities for administration and services. Six of the 11 buildings are at least 70 years old, and site assessments by Harriman found major deficiencies.
The Facilities Committee plans to issue its recommendation to the board in December for how much the district should seek to borrow to repair or replace its oldest buildings.
Taxpayer frustration
About 40 residents attended the district’s Nov. 9 budget forum in Topsham. Board members said it was a surprisingly large number.
At least 10 audience members spoke, and their message was consistent: The district needs to be aggressive about cutting expenses this year because many residents can’t absorb another property tax increase.
Alison Hawkes, a former school board member who lives in Cundy’s Harbor, said she understands how hard it is to meet students’ educational needs while keeping costs under control. Still, she said the district needs to find new ways to cut spending.
“It’s a game that you’re playing with the lives of your community,” Hawkes told the board. “You have to get creative. You have to do different stuff.”
Board members at the forum expressed sympathy and said they would work to keep costs down where possible. But they said strict state requirements and an already lean operation leave little room for major cuts.
“What we spend the money on is our core (programs),” said board Chair Hutson Hayward, of Bowdoinham. “I like (the idea of cuts) in theory, but in practice, I don’t think we’ve got a lot of programs that are beyond the pale.”
Some residents also urged local officials to pressure state lawmakers to ease the burden on local property taxpayers.
Although Maine law requires the state to cover 55% of essential public education costs statewide, the share varies considerably among school districts. The funding formula relies heavily on property valuations to determine how much communities can afford to contribute.
In MSAD 75, state funding accounts for about 37% of the current budget, while local taxpayers cover about 61%. The district also raises millions more than the state funding formula requires to cover educational expenses.
Lawmakers approved changes to the formula earlier this year, including adjustments intended to better account for local poverty rates and regional costs. Those changes will take effect in the upcoming budget year, although their impact on MSAD 75 remains uncertain.
Bond impact significant
The district would need to borrow an estimated $135 million to immediately address all of the proposed building renovations and replacements recommended in Harriman’s facilities master plan, including the construction of a new Harpswell Community School.
Based on a preliminary analysis by district Business Manager Evan Howard, a $135 million bond would increase annual property taxes on a representative home by roughly $1,000 under a 20-year repayment plan, or $1,500 under a 10-year plan.
The impact would vary among the district’s four towns. In Harpswell, the estimated annual increase would be about $950 for a typical home assessed at $600,000 under the 20-year plan, or $1,400 under the 10-year plan. In Topsham, the increases would be $1,400 and $2,100, respectively, for a typical home assessed at $500,000.
Spreading repayment over 20 years would reduce the annual tax burden but substantially increase the cost of borrowing. The district would pay an estimated $64.4 million in interest over 20 years, compared with $27.7 million over 10 years — a difference of $36.7 million.
The projections are based on preliminary borrowing rates from September and assume the towns would share the costs in the same proportions as their contributions to the district’s current operating budget. Actual tax impacts would depend on the amount borrowed, interest rates, property valuations and other factors.
The estimates reflect the years with the highest debt payments — 2028-29 for the 10-year bond and 2029-30 for the 20-year bond. Annual payments would decline thereafter.
At the Nov. 12 meeting, board members said they could opt to put off many of the needed facility repairs to dramatically lower borrowing costs. However, they said years of deferred decisions have increased the urgency of repairs.
“We recognize that this can’s been kicked down the road to this moment for many decades,” said board member Gregory Greenleaf, of Harpswell. “I just don’t think we can kick the can (any further). Our kids deserve good facilities to learn.”
The district’s Finance Committee is scheduled to meet Dec. 7 to review public feedback from the Nov. 9 forum and establish goals for the 2027-28 budget.
Detailed budget deliberations will begin in January, with Superintendent of Schools Heidi O’Leary expected to present budget recommendations in March. Voters will consider the final proposal at a district budget meeting May 20, followed by a validation referendum June 8.